The Southern Poverty Law Center Is the Real Hate Machine – The American Spectator | USA News and PoliticsThe American Spectator

The Southern Poverty Law Center (SPLC) once fought the good fight. They took on the Ku Klux Klan and sued them into oblivion. This was a group that helped dismantle the architecture of violent racism in the American South. But that era is long gone. It’s dead. Well and truly buried.

What remains is not a civil rights watchdog but a well-financed paranoia machine — bloated, sanctimonious, and politically drunk on its own self-righteousness. (RELATED: The Loser of the Year: The Southern Poverty Law Center)

Their latest spectacle — sounding the alarm on “Active Clubs” and their supposed connections to Patriot Front — might sound serious at first glance. White nationalist groups using combat sports to radicalize should raise eyebrows. But context matters. And nuance matters more. The SPLC, however, isn’t in the nuance business. It’s in the moral panic business. They’ll grab the faintest whiff of association and present it as imminent domestic terror. Because they need you frightened, and they need someone to blame.

Here’s the truth: the SPLC has quietly morphed into a branding agency. One that trades in enemies. The more hate groups they list, the more donations roll in. And so, like a modern-day Inquisition with a PayPal account, they cast the net wide and sloppy — lumping Catholic school networks with skinhead militias, mainstream conservative nonprofits with literal neo-Nazis. A group doesn’t have to advocate violence to earn the SPLC’s scarlet letter. All it has to do is disagree.

This ideological mission creep isn’t some abstract concern — it has real consequences. People have lost jobs, platforms, reputations, and funding based on the SPLC’s unchallenged accusations. Their so-called “hate map” has been cited by journalists, lawmakers, and even the FBI. And yet there’s no transparency, no oversight, and no clear standards for inclusion. They once labeled Maajid Nawaz, a former radical who now campaigns against Islamic extremism, a hate figure. Why? Because he questioned regressive Islamist practices and didn’t toe the progressive line. He sued them and won a $3.4 million settlement. But most people don’t have the means to fight back.

And don’t forget, this is the same organization that has been called out by its own staff for being a sham and incredibly discriminatory. In 2019, a wave of resignations and internal complaints exposed a workplace culture of racism and misogyny. The SPLC — America’s self-declared referee on hate — was itself a cesspool of institutional bigotry. Their co-founder, Morris Dees, was quietly pushed out amid sexual misconduct allegations and long-whispered scandals. The organization that lectures the nation about justice couldn’t even clean its own house.

But here’s the most damning thing: the SPLC doesn’t just undermine trust in itself — it undermines trust in the very idea of fighting hate. When everyone is labeled a bigot, the word loses all meaning. When they claim the Republican National Committee is flirting with fascism, or that parental rights organizations are “extremist,” it flattens the moral terrain. It lets the real monsters hide in the crowd. The SPLC has become so addicted to its own outrage machine that it confuses disagreement with danger, debate with violence.

And this isn’t just a left-right issue. It’s a civic one. Free speech, dissent, religious liberty — these are the things the SPLC used to champion. Now they blacklist. They smear. They cheer when PayPal cuts off critics or when YouTube bans the “wrong” kind of speech. They aren’t defending democracy. They’re narrowing it. (RELATED: Another Dot on the ‘Hate Map’)

Obviously, white nationalist groups exist. Some are growing. They are toxic and dangerous and deserve to be exposed. But if you put that task in the hands of a deeply partisan, ethically tainted nonprofit that can’t tell the difference between a hate crime and a heterodox opinion, you make the problem worse. You hand extremists exactly what they want: evidence that the system is rigged. That every criticism is met not with argument, but with cancellation.

And they’re not wrong.

In an age when trust is in tatters and every institution feels like a psyop, the SPLC should be a guiding light. Instead, it’s become a cudgel. It doesn’t illuminate. It intimidates. It doesn’t investigate. It accuses. And worst of all, it wields immense cultural power without ever being held accountable.

So, no, the Southern Poverty Law Center should not be treated as a moral authority. It is not the conscience of the republic. It is a fundraising juggernaut wrapped in a nonprofit’s clothing, trading fear for power and smears for influence. We don’t need watchdogs who bark at shadows. We need watchdogs who know the difference between a threat and a political inconvenience, and don’t bite just because the check cleared.

READ MORE from John Mac Ghlionn:

Confessions of a Jimmy Fallon Fan

Pope Leo Is Tweeting

David Brooks Still Can’t Say the Word ‘God’