ByteDance thinks Americans are fools. The Chinese tech giant’s latest maneuver — building a “new app” to replace TikTok while keeping the same owners, same code, same data flows — represents corporate gaslighting at its finest. Come September, when this rebranded surveillance tool launches, we’re supposed to breathe easy and move on.
We shouldn’t.
What ByteDance offers isn’t a solution. It’s a shell game designed to preserve Chinese intelligence operations on American soil while politicians declare victory.
The facts are straightforward. TikTok faces a legal deadline: sell to American companies or shut down. ByteDance’s response? Create a new app that looks different but changes nothing that matters. Same algorithms. Same data collection. Same personnel running the show. The only difference is the name on the corporate letterhead. (RELATED: TikTok Ban Necessary to Thwart CCP)
Call it a divestment if you like, but nothing meaningful changes except the optics. Control isn’t transferred with paperwork; it’s transferred when the pipelines are severed. This isn’t happening.
Under the proposed deal, ByteDance retains a 20 percent stake, while American investors walk away with a shiny 50 percent. Sounds like a win, until you realize these percentages are theatre. Numbers slapped on a façade to pacify Washington, while the actual scaffolding underneath remains unmistakably Chinese. It’s like selling someone your house but keeping copies of every key, memorizing the alarm code, and leaving microphones in every wall. The “new owners” get the title and the bills. The old owners keep the access.
And access is everything.
They don’t need majority ownership when they still control the wiring — the engineers, the architecture, the data pathways. The real power isn’t in shares. It’s in sustained influence.
What’s unfolding is a national security failure with a Silicon Valley paint job.
The timeline alone exposes the absurdity. TikTok, in its current form, will continue to operate at full throttle until March 2026, giving Beijing many more months to mine the American psyche without interruption. To watch their faces. Listen to their voices. Track their moods. Monitor their habits. Not once, not occasionally, but constantly. Each swipe offers a new piece of the puzzle. Each pause marks emotional hesitation, political interest, latent insecurity. Every viral trend is more than a joke; it’s raw material for reverse-engineering a generation. A feedback loop of surveillance disguised as fun.
This is behavioral mapping at a national scale, a living experiment in psychological manipulation. And we’re still feeding it. (RELATED: China’s War Is Here — Most Americans Are Blind to It)
Control the algorithm, and you control perception. You don’t need tanks when you have tabs on 170 million Americans and the power to shape what they think, feel, and fear. You don’t need spies when users confess everything to their front-facing cameras.
What actually changes under this cosmetic ownership reshuffle? Very little, I suggest,
Maybe the app’s logo. A couple of legal documents notarized in Delaware. That’s window dressing.
What doesn’t change is the core machinery — the spine of the system. The codebase stays intact. Those who built the recommendation engine, tuned its triggers, and refined it to capture and steer attention with surgical precision? Still there. Their fingerprints are embedded in every scroll. The system doesn’t need to sit in Beijing to serve Beijing. The data flows are already mapped. The behavioral protocols already tested. The intelligence already extracted.
Changing the name on the deed doesn’t erase the blueprints. Software doesn’t forget, and neither do the people who created it.
What’s unfolding is a national security failure with a Silicon Valley paint job.
Because while the U.S. government dithers over equity splits, ByteDance retains what truly matters — intellectual leverage. The deep familiarity with American behavioral patterns, cultural fault lines, generational anxieties. This isn’t some abstract threat. This is an adversarial state with a long-term strategy, quietly embedding itself into the neural pathways of an entire generation.
TikTok is definitely addictive, but it’s also instructive. It teaches kids what to care about, what to laugh at, what to ignore, and what to hate. It’s the closest thing to mind control the 21st century has built, and we’re handing it back to its original designers, just with a fresh coat of domestic lipstick.
Imagine the reverse. Imagine an American company building an app used by 700 million Chinese citizens, capturing facial biometrics, location data, keystrokes, and real-time sentiment. Then imagine Beijing tolerating a deal where the platform remains American-engineered, but the ownership is shuffled around like Monopoly shares.
They wouldn’t allow it. They haven’t allowed it. Because, unlike Washington, they understand power doesn’t lie in paperwork. It lies in control over systems — systems that shape culture, direct attention, and mine vulnerabilities.
American officials face a choice between genuine security and elaborate theater. The current arrangement offers the worst of both worlds — the appearance of action combined with the reality of continued exposure. It’s a solution that solves nothing while pretending to solve everything.
The TikTok question was never about commerce or competition. It was about sovereignty in the digital age. This cosmetic restructuring preserves Chinese control while providing American politicians with cover. The surveillance continues. The data flows persist. The influence operations remain intact.
Only the marketing has changed. The threat remains the same. The alarm bells should ring louder, not softer. Because ByteDance is counting on American complacency to pull off the intelligence coup of the century.
READ MORE from John Mac Ghlionn: